{"data":{"event":{"id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","slug":"new-hampshire-biden-ai-robocall","title":"AI Biden voice robocalls target New Hampshire primary voters","short_summary":"On 21 January 2024 thousands of New Hampshire voters received spoofed calls using an ElevenLabs-cloned Biden voice telling them not to vote; the FCC later fined Steve Kramer $6 million and Lingo Telecom $1 million.","full_description":"The deepfake message urged Democrats to save their vote for November. Kramer was also criminally charged in New Hampshire. Election officials and the FCC treated the campaign as voter suppression. Turnout effects were not isolated in a causal study, but the calls and enforcement are documented.","ledger_type":"harm","primary_domain_id":"056250cf-05f4-4116-957c-78323ed7f8cf","event_status":"verified","event_date":"2024-01-21T00:00:00.000Z","discovery_date":"2024-01-21T00:00:00.000Z","first_published_date":"2024-01-21T00:00:00.000Z","last_reviewed_date":"2026-10-28T00:00:00.000Z","geographic_scope":"New Hampshire, United States","affected_population":"Thousands of New Hampshire Democratic primary voters who received the calls","base_impact_tier":2,"base_score":"3.00","attribution_multiplier":"0.4500","evidence_multiplier":"0.8500","realization_multiplier":"0.8000","durability_multiplier":"0.4000","current_event_score":"0.183600","confidence_level":"high","score_explanation":"Thousands of deceptive AI-voice political calls with no demonstrated turnout or election effect are Significant civic harm (tier 2), not Major. This is not a risk index. Voice model plus human organizer (0.45). FCC forfeiture is strong evidence. Realization is the calls themselves. Transient election event.","methodology_version_id":"8745541b-0f8e-4d5a-9b47-5291d3813a8d","original_methodology_version_id":"d7881163-fb23-4e71-8625-bac1a8662c0f","published_at":"2024-01-21T00:00:00.000Z","created_at":"2026-09-13T20:47:20.075Z","updated_at":"2026-10-28T20:22:47.621Z","flags":[],"domain_name":"Computer Science","domain_slug":"computer-science","methodology_version":"0.2"},"contributions":[{"id":"d399c60e-b9d8-4195-a282-765956b95a9f","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":"fc4de42b-f02b-442c-87d3-6c483e70241f","role_description":"Cloned a Biden-like voice used in the robocall audio.","attribution_multiplier":"0.4500","credit_share":"0.5000","contribution_score":"0.183600","attribution_rationale":"The synthetic voice was generated with ElevenLabs; Kramer designed and placed the calls.","attribution_confidence":"medium","first_used_date":"2024-01-21T00:00:00.000Z","model_version_if_known":null,"review_status":"approved","created_at":"2026-09-13T20:47:20.075Z","model_slug":"elevenlabs-voice-model","model_name":"ElevenLabs Voice Model","identity_class":"named_release","is_internal":false,"family_name":"ElevenLabs","family_slug":"elevenlabs-elevenlabs","organization_name":"ElevenLabs","organization_slug":"elevenlabs"}],"sources":[{"id":"51566600-2563-4c05-a63f-83e31c92379b","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","url":"https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-24-104A1.pdf","canonical_url":"https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-24-104A1.pdf","source_type":"regulatory_record","publisher":"Federal Communications Commission","author":null,"publication_date":"2024-09-30T00:00:00.000Z","retrieved_at":"2026-09-13T20:47:20.075Z","title":"In the Matter of Steve Kramer, Forfeiture Order FCC 24-104","excerpt":null,"content_hash":null,"source_reliability_class":"medium","is_primary_source":true,"is_independent":true,"is_peer_reviewed":false,"archived_url":null,"created_at":"2026-09-13T20:47:20.075Z"},{"id":"1b06a943-7be2-415c-a98f-8e227617e887","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","url":"https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-issues-6m-fine-nh-robocalls","canonical_url":"https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-issues-6m-fine-nh-robocalls","source_type":"regulatory_record","publisher":"FCC","author":null,"publication_date":"2024-09-30T00:00:00.000Z","retrieved_at":"2026-09-13T20:47:20.075Z","title":"FCC Issues $6M Fine For N.H. Robocalls","excerpt":null,"content_hash":null,"source_reliability_class":"medium","is_primary_source":true,"is_independent":true,"is_peer_reviewed":false,"archived_url":null,"created_at":"2026-09-13T20:47:20.075Z"},{"id":"c9f7e6cf-5df6-4c90-ba9b-d51079a0ab51","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","url":"https://www.aisi.gov.uk/blog/advancing-voice-ai-security-with-elevenlabs","canonical_url":"https://www.aisi.gov.uk/blog/advancing-voice-ai-security-with-elevenlabs","source_type":"other","publisher":"UK AISI Blog","author":null,"publication_date":"2026-09-17T00:00:00.000Z","retrieved_at":"2026-09-17T03:00:51.890Z","title":"Advancing AI voice security with ElevenLabs","excerpt":"Advancing AI voice security with ElevenLabs","content_hash":null,"source_reliability_class":"medium","is_primary_source":false,"is_independent":true,"is_peer_reviewed":false,"archived_url":null,"created_at":"2026-09-17T03:00:51.890Z"}],"claims":[{"id":"823c1bf3-62c4-421b-9062-d45088048224","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","claim_text":"Spoofed robocalls used a generative Biden voice to discourage New Hampshire primary voting, leading to FCC forfeitures.","claim_type":"outcome","claim_status":"supported","confidence_score":null,"created_at":"2026-10-28T20:22:47.621Z","updated_at":"2026-10-28T20:22:47.621Z"}],"revisions":[{"id":"1866c98a-035b-474d-8ec7-da11c89cf945","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.000000","new_score":"0.612000","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"evidence":0.85,"base_score":10,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Initial adjudicated seed score under methodology 0.1.","trigger_type":"seed","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-09-13T20:47:20.075Z"},{"id":"83d4cdad-75d2-4abc-99bd-4b994d1abe00","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.612000","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-09-14T02:35:26.290Z"},{"id":"2fca41af-2167-4f7e-9f2b-91aeee13c6b9","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-09-17T00:37:09.904Z"},{"id":"68173b52-a09c-4958-b6d9-3671155bc81d","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{"tier":2,"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"new_factors":{"tier":2,"models":["fc4de42b-f02b-442c-87d3-6c483e70241f"],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Ingest update: added a follow-up source.","trigger_type":"ingest_update","trigger_source_ids":["c9f7e6cf-5df6-4c90-ba9b-d51079a0ab51"],"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-09-17T03:00:51.906Z"},{"id":"ce0b128e-a1cd-4a73-9cb7-1833d0532c7f","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-09-18T19:11:40.608Z"},{"id":"2cc176e0-f9e8-402a-9bf7-dc00fd9318f0","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-09-19T00:53:33.692Z"},{"id":"00b05712-08d3-4682-914a-6e0291a2301f","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-09-21T01:54:16.553Z"},{"id":"30913668-d71f-4f39-9df3-436ebd94655d","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-10-06T23:04:40.642Z"},{"id":"7b13557c-4612-4f9e-8d23-f0e7fadb454c","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-10-07T16:12:13.690Z"},{"id":"2c214946-9394-4985-aea5-e18620b3c7d6","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-10-11T00:50:27.558Z"},{"id":"579577c8-5b94-4087-997a-4af37547dcf4","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-10-11T00:51:25.860Z"},{"id":"96b26ff7-8461-4049-8754-f272bc90ae26","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-10-21T19:26:46.597Z"},{"id":"04b5580a-b974-425a-82f7-b75f0c48251f","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-10-24T18:59:49.597Z"},{"id":"24a2947f-c2b8-46c9-b991-dd4e06c48303","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-10-27T20:16:14.720Z"},{"id":"25fd9665-f947-457f-9f2e-6a86761792d3","event_id":"46fc71e7-4c17-408e-95dc-2c30952013e1","model_id":null,"previous_score":"0.183600","new_score":"0.183600","previous_factors":{},"new_factors":{"flags":[],"evidence":0.85,"base_score":3,"durability":0.4,"attribution":0.45,"realization":0.8},"change_reason":"Methodology 0.2: realized civic incident without demonstrated electoral effect is Significant harm, not Major.","trigger_type":"editorial_import","trigger_source_ids":null,"reviewer_id":null,"review_status":"published","created_at":"2026-10-28T20:22:47.621Z"}],"secondary":[]},"methodology_version":"0.1"}